GUEST COLUMN: Shorter’s alumni want more administrative accountability
by KENNETH E. HILL, Guest Columnist
Jul 16, 2012 | 6373 views | 15 15 comments | 32 32 recommendations | email to a friend | print
FOR NEARLY 50 years, my wife and I have been involved in one way or another at Shorter.

We both graduated in the ’60s. Our two children and son-in-law graduated in the ’90s. Shorter has always been like a family, and we loved to return for graduations and other special events. We were always welcomed and most of the faculty and staff knew us. Students we worked with over the years were encouraged to attend Shorter. Some did attend. Some received scholarships.

For several decades, my wife and I have served on the Alumni Governing Board during which there were several alumni director and college president changes. Never have we witnessed anything like this past year. The new administration has perpetrated fear and uncertainty that I have not seen in a long time. Dishonesty runs rampant. The new administration quickly attacked the fine arts by disallowing a popular opera because of the mentioning of strong drink. However, they did allow a flash mob dance to a song with blatantly vulgar lyrics to be performed in the dining hall. This flash mob was planned, led and performed in by the same dean whose “Christ-Centered Critical Thinking” plan is approved for the university.

THOUGH ATTENTION to the vulgarity of the lyrics was called to the president, provost, and dean, no acknowledgement of error or apology for the flash mob song choice has been made. We might note also that during the performance, the president’s wife was seen laughing and applauding. In another situation, at the awards presentation during Celebrate Shorter in early April, the listing of the scholarship honoring a much loved faculty member omitted that name from the printed program with another name being given to the scholarship. Though attention of this omission and change of names also was called to the president, provost and dean of that area, no acknowledgement or apology was ever made.

Since November 2011, there have been many articles and letters written, both pro and con, about the debacle at Shorter University. Some even declared Shorter evil and supported the change to a “Christian” institution. The editor of The Christian Index, the Georgia Baptist Convention’s newspaper, said he applauded what Dr. Dowless was doing. Some said there is a cancer that needs to be removed. Shorter has always been a Christian school. However, it is not a convent or monastery. Most of us are sad and angry to see our beloved Shorter destroyed in such a devious way.

WHERE WAS the Alumni Governing Board during all the controversy? I can say that we tried. Initially, The director of Alumni Affairs and the president of the Alumni Governing Board did meet with Dr. Dowless. Things were more positive at our next meeting but soon began to crumble. At the following meeting, some alumni had tried to speak with Dr. Dowless to encourage him to move more carefully. The lifestyle statement was out and the word began to spread over the social media network.

There were other meetings with Dr. Dowless by alumni, faculty and others, to no avail. He would not change his position on the lifestyle statement. Those not signing the lifestyle statement faced termination. More than 70 faculty and staff have left for one reason or another. It seems obvious to most that the precarious environment at Shorter caused many to leave. It certainly is not normal for so many to leave, were it not for the conditions placed upon them at Shorter by Dr. Dowless and others.

Alumni trust in the administration became greatly diminished. Some of the alumni along with AGB members organized a protest at the bottom of the hill, in November 2011. It was organized legally through the Rome police, and was carried out appropriately.

A NUMBER of AGB members, as well as alumni and interested citizens from Rome and other parts of Georgia attended. Only one AGB member attended the inauguration that was taking place at the same time. Another protest, arranged according to the regulations of the Rome police in the spring of 2012, occurred peacefully in the rain.

I sometimes have to pinch myself to make sure I am not in a bad dream. The debacle at Shorter is a bad dream for many of us — a bad dream that may never disappear. Who are the people who have taken Shorter from us? How did such a heinous and villainous act slip by us? Someone said recently, “They fired a warning shot many years ago and the main attack has just arrived.”

Who would cause a family to have to pack up and move when they really did not want to? Who would coerce anyone to sign a ridiculous lifestyle statement and subjugate those who remain? Who are those who allow a sickening flash dance song with sickening lyrics played to a dance by faculty and staff?

They will soon burn books and art that have stood the test of time. Who are they?

THEY ARE the fundamentalists who took over the Southern Baptist Convention decades ago. They bring the message of inerrancy and the infallible word. They espouse and advocate a philosophy that subjugates women to a level less than men. Only men can be pastors. Women may be qualified, but men must be the pastors of the churches. They refuse to have fellowship with anyone who might not believe as they do. These same people approve of pastors having sole authority in the church. (I always thought that Christ was the sole authority.) In order to have a place of leadership in the denomination, one must adhere to their beliefs only. These same people accused Jimmy Carter of “secular humanism”, urging him to return to Christianity. They also had the audacity to question the faith of messengers to the SBC from Bill Clinton’s church. Even missionaries in the field had their faith questioned. Are we surprised to see what happened at Shorter? They have left in their wake a trail of disenfranchised people including pastors, associates, faculty and staff of Baptist colleges, universities and seminaries — and the list goes on.

What saddens me most in this dilemma is that I know and believe that there are members of SBC churches who are not true fundamentalists.

IT IS DIFFICULT to believe that anyone would want to see a school like Shorter destroyed. It was a beautiful liberal arts college. There were graduates who became teachers, principals, pastors, lawyers, doctors, opera singers, gospel singers, and other professional people. These graduates have made and are making our world a better place. Go to www.saveourshorter.com to read more about the Shorter dilemma.

Kenneth E. Hill of Rome is a 1964 graduate of Shorter College and a former member of the college’s Alumni Governing Board.

Comments
(15)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Almost_Anonymous
|
July 19, 2012
I hear Sandra Terry is now gone from Shorter, too, but she's still shown as the AVP of Intercultural Services & Programs on the organizational chart.

Does anyone know if she's still there? If not, who's taken her place?

Thanks!
Almost_Anonymous
|
July 16, 2012
Well, now the Save Our Shorter folks are claiming the new HR director has already left after barely a month on the job.

Here's last month's article announcing his hiring.

http://rn-t.com/view/full_story/18898496/article-Shorter-University-welcomes-Wayne-Phipps-as-director-of-Human-Resources?instance=article_results

Does anyone know the story on this? I hope they're wrong.

Thanks.
Almost_Anonymous
|
July 17, 2012
Can someone list the changes to Shorter's organization that are not shown in their current organizational chart:

www.shorter.edu/about/organizational_chart.pdf

Here are some that I'm aware of:

*The new Executive VP is not shown

*The HR director quit

*The Provost retired abruptly

*The Dean of Nursing went to Berry. I think the two remaining instructors are co-deans, but that's not shown on this chart.

I've heard that the Vice President of Enrollment Management has also left -- is that true?

This chart shows Debra Faust as Vice President of Student Affairs and Dean of Students but elsewhere on the Shorter website, Corey Humphries is shown as Vice President of Student Affairs (but not Dean of Students). Did Ms. Faust quit? Get reassigned? Is there a separate Dean of Students.

What about the Dean of Education - is it still Sandra Leslie? Somewhere I though I tread they were bringing in someone from North Greenville or Charleston-Southern to replace her.
Almost_Anonymous
|
July 17, 2012
OK, I found the info on the Dean of Education. They did replace Dr. Leslie; here's the info:

http://www.shorter.edu/about/news/2012/06_06_12_norma_harper.htm
Almost_Anonymous
|
July 18, 2012
Maybe the SaveOurShorter people read these threads??

They just posted something explaining Debra Faust's demotion/replacement/transfer or whatever it is:

http://saveourshorter.com/2012/07/18/eighty-two-departures-and-counting/#comments
Almost_Anonymous
|
July 18, 2012
More surprising -- they're claiming Shorter fired Sallie Samples!!

Anybody know why they did that???
ShorterProf
|
July 18, 2012
They did fire Sallie Samples. After 3 weeks on the job, Norma Harper (who followed Dowless here from Charleston) came in and fired a 22-year employee who always went above and beyond the call in her job. She was a trusted confidant to students and a tireless & cheerful worker. None of it makes sense other than these people now running Shorter are pure EVIL (and Norma Harper probably has a relative who needs a job)!
Almost_Anonymous
|
July 18, 2012
Well, ShorterProf, I think calling Dr. Dowless and his new team pure EVIL isn't right.

But I am perplexed and saddened by Ms. Samples' sacking.

Did anybody give a reason?

If nothing else, they need some continuity, especially in administrative and secretarial positions as they navigate all the changes.

Also, this will just needlessly upset the hundreds of students and alumni that are fans of Ms. Samples. Why do this now? It's not as if she didn't sign the agreement (and live up to it). The timing seems even more boneheaded than the decision itself. How does this advance Dr. Dowless' vision for Shorter? Probably not much. How does it impede it -- well, why start all these unproductive sideshows when the main battle is still in doubt.
ShorterProf
|
July 18, 2012
Referring to "those people" as evil is not just a case of me calling them names. That is my honest opinion of them. I get chills when I see Don.

I could have thrown in lying, self-serving, manipulative, narrow minded pinheads, but most of that goes without saying...and would be insulting to just normal pinheads.
Almost_Anonymous
|
July 18, 2012
Looks like Brenau was quick to snatch up Shorter's outgoing Dean of Education, Dr. Leslie. Here's the announcement:

http://www.accessnorthga.com/detail.php?n=250813
AbsoluteMind
|
July 16, 2012
Thank you, Mr. Hill, for a column that expresses the sentiments of so many of us. Alumni have been discarded like yesterday's garbage. It will be interesting to see how well they do without our financial support and our "selling" Shorter to prospective students.

I hope the Baptist churches are putting the squeeze on their members to get their children into the school. But that creates a problem - the GBC is going to have to come up with a lot more scholarship money.

Almost - I don't think they'll be seeing a lot of the same donors that they had. For one thing, faculty and staff used to make donations - some of them rather substantial, given their salaries.

My guess is that things were in a turmoil last year when they were pushing Dr. Newman out the door and of course, this year, if you did a comparison, there would be a lot of long-time donors missing, I'd bet.
Almost_Anonymous
|
July 16, 2012
Every year, Shorter used to publish the "President's Report and Honor Roll of Donors" and listed all its donors by category:

Founders’ Circle ($25,000 and up)

Trustees’ Circle ($10,000 to $24,999)

President’s Circle ($5,000 to $9,999)

Provost’s Circle ($1,000 to $4,999)

etc.

This was before Dr. Dowless became President; has anyone seen the list of donors for this year or last?
Almost_Anonymous
|
July 17, 2012
Shorter seemed a few years back to be announcing major gift from different donors fairly often.

I though I hadn't seen any new announcements in a while so I went and looked at Shorter's news archive; the last time they announced any big gifts was in February 2010:

http://www.shorter.edu/about/news/news_archives.htm

Where's the love these days?
Almost_Anonymous
|
July 16, 2012
It's depressing to see so many Shorter alumni walking away from Shorter these days.

What can the current administration do to try to rebuild bridges to these people?
Almost_Anonymous
|
July 16, 2012
Here's a sample of the people that were kicked off Shorter’s board in 2006; note that all were active churchgoers and the majority were Baptists:

Frank Barron — Coca Cola, major local philanthropist, Barron Stadium, etc

Robert Ledbetter - real estate — donated Shorter’s business school)

Kathy Engeman - donated over $100,000 in one year

Emmanuel McCall - head of the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship

Joel Snider - First Baptist Church, Rome

Michael Thurmond - Georgia Labor Commissioner

Patsy Drummond - husband was CEO of BellSouth Communications

Cindy Yancey Lester - prominent, generous local family (State Mutual, etc.)

Roger Smith - CEO of Citizens First Bank

Barry Hurley - Chairman of Heritage First Bank

Ronnie Wallace - Mayor and prominent banker

Buford Harbin - Harbin Clinic, etc.

Is the current Board of Trustees as generous or well-connected? Is it possible to get some of these generous people above giving to Shorter again before it's too late?

I think the CEO of Pirelli used to be on the board, too, didn't he?
Postings are not edited and are the responsibility of the author. You agree not to post comments that are abusive, threatening or obscene. Postings may be removed at our discretion.